Customer Reviews
Awesome taste, kids and adults loved it!
It brings back Grand Cayman Island vacation memories :)
Review by Eric / (Posted on 8/1/2017)
This is the BEST Rum cake I have had since I left Queens, NY!! The taste is amazing, I will be buying more from you.
Review by Frenchy / (Posted on 6/9/2017)
We made impulse buy on our way back from visiting my wifes family in Barbados. After my third piece I told my wife "I have my my decision, I'll never eat another piece of cake again unless it's a Tortuga Rum Cake!" My taste buds will never be the same!
Review by Jay L Jr. / (Posted on 3/20/2017)
This cake really is the World's Best, I use to try to bake my own rum cake.
Review by Mo / (Posted on 2/24/2017)
Wow! Another delicious rum cake from Tortuga. Not only are Tortuga's mouthwatering rum cakes delicious, they are "substantially" dense, extremely moist & have a very long shelf life. I recommend taking advantage of their "specials & discounts" throughout the year & stock up on all of your favorite flavors & Christmas gifts. Our favorites are the original, pineapple & of course, chocolate.
Review by Drew / (Posted on 12/16/2016)
Beyond love them! All are great, but the original it excellent... and my favorite! My friend asked me to grap her a box of 6 on my way back from the Bahamas. I sampled one at the shop.... and had a new addiction. I have 2-4 oz cakes away, but have eaten a 16 oz and 1.5 of the4 oz. cakes... with 2 -4 oz cakes left since last Sunday. I have already ordered 9 - 16 oz cakes for special clients for Thanksgiving and our agents more 4 oz ones since they absolutely loved them.
Review by Tracy / (Posted on 10/27/2016)
The aroma of the rum mixed with the succulent cake had me say MMMMM MMMM MMM out loud! This is the main reason me and family keep coming back to the Cayman!
Review by Johnnie / (Posted on 4/14/2015)
I bought this locally and was so amazed, I'm buying more for Christmas gifts. The cake is super moist, soft, melts in your mouth. I cannot describe the taste. It's different than anything I've ever had, and as good as any cake I have ever, ever had. There is no raw alcohol taste, everything is very gentle, very mellow. I can see all kinds of ways to make this a one of a kind dessert that will have your friends and neighbors raving. Several good serving suggestions in the box . Warm or cold, everyone in your family will love this.
Review by Zoe / (Posted on 4/14/2015)
We just went to Grand Cayman for the first time and bought this cake that everyone said we needed to try. I purchased just one, didn't want to get too much if I didn't like it. When we got back on the ship we opened it and had some -- Holy Mother of God!!!! I wanted to jump off the ship and swim back to shore to get some more. We will be ordering on line to get more, I ate all 33 oz's my self in one day. Great stuff!!!!
Review by Mark / (Posted on 4/14/2015)
I just wanted to let you know that the rumcake you gave for the Father's Day giveaway on the Mary's Cup of Tea blog was fantastic. I could smell the rum as soon as I opened the package. I've eaten rum cakes before but none came close to yours. I was just disappointed that I had to let my hubby have a little of it. I could have eaten it all myself.
Review by Karen / (Posted on 4/14/2015)
The gift that is always appreciated
This rumcake is the greatest gift ever. My family and friends have come to expect this every year and I have never gotten so much positive feedback from my gifts!!!!!!!!!!! the best part is I get to treat myself and stock up for myself while I am at it ... Highly recommended !!
Review by John S. / (Posted on 4/14/2015)
Excellent cake, but FedEx delivery has to go! My cakes are crushed every time and while still delicious, unable to serve!
Review by Liz Vining / (Posted on 4/14/2015)
Golden Vanilla Rum Cake all the way!
Man this thing is good! A friend went to Cayman and brought it back and I had to order 1 right away. Got it in 3 days. Great product and Great service.
Review by Dexter B. / (Posted on 4/14/2015)
It's delicious and always a big hit with our staff!
Review by Carlos / (Posted on 4/14/2015)
This is definitely the best flavor! Sure, all of them are amazing, but nothing is better then the original!
Review by David W. / (Posted on 4/14/2015)
Sign Up for Special Email Offers
Get social